An antitrust lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron of coordinating to restrict supplies of DDR4 memory will proceed in California after a judge rejected the companies’ requests to dismiss the case. The ruling keeps alive claims brought by 17 consumers and small businesses over the pricing and availability of memory used in computers and other electronic devices.
The lawsuit, filed in June, alleges that the three manufacturers reduced DDR4 production volumes in late 2022 as they redirected capacity toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM, used in systems designed for artificial intelligence. The plaintiffs contend that the companies’ actions helped preserve high prices and margins during a period when demand for memory was strong.
Claims focus on supply and pricing
According to the allegations, the companies’ decisions were coordinated rather than independent. The plaintiffs say the manufacturers could reduce output without losing all of their sales to competitors because Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron together control more than 90% of the DRAM market. That concentration, the complaint argues, left customers with limited alternatives when DDR4 supplies tightened.
| Issue in the lawsuit | What the plaintiffs allege |
|---|---|
| Products | DDR4 memory and related DRAM products |
| Companies named | Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron |
| Market position | The three companies control more than 90% of the DRAM market |
| Price increase alleged | More than 700% over a year and a half |
The complaint also questions why production of DDR4 and DDR5 did not expand as shortages developed. It alleges that prices increased by more than 700% over a year and a half, and argues that the increase was the result of deliberate supply management. The companies’ decision-making around Micron’s Crucial consumer-memory brand is also cited by the plaintiffs as part of their case.
Companies point to AI-related demand
Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron have denied that their actions were coordinated. Their position, as described in reporting on the case, is that production decisions were made independently and reflected normal market responses to growing demand for AI-focused memory chips. The companies sought dismissal before the case could proceed further, but the judge’s decision means the allegations will continue to be examined in court.
- The case was filed in June by 17 consumers and small businesses.
- The complaint centers on alleged reductions in DDR4 production during a shift toward HBM.
- The judge’s decision allows the lawsuit to continue; it does not establish that the companies violated antitrust law.
The litigation places the memory industry’s transition toward HBM under additional scrutiny. HBM has become increasingly important to AI systems, while DDR4 remains part of the supply chain for personal computers and other electronics. The case will now move forward with the plaintiffs’ allegations contested by the three manufacturers.